E作者kubturub (kubturub)
看板Eng-Class
標題[文法] but和although
時間Sat Mar 10 16:57:56 2018
題目：
Businesses and jobs – such as professional typists, video store clerks, or
file clerks – are going out of existence. New ones are comping in, _____
probably not as quickly as the ones going out.
解答是but，但有另一個選項是although，想問為什麼不能選although？
謝謝！
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 123.192.192.237
※ 文章網址: https://webptt.com/m.aspx?n=bbs/Eng-Class/M.1520672279.A.AD5.html
1F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 沒主詞只能用連結詞而非副詞子句 03/11 01:07
2F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 加上有逗點更不會是although 03/11 01:08
3F：→ kubturub: 但although也是連接詞吧? 03/11 02:06
4F：→ SINORNITHOSA: nope 03/11 12:19
5F：→ kubturub: goo.gl/YcBZ2H 03/11 14:06
6F：→ kubturub: although是連接詞沒錯啊 03/11 14:07
7F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 抱歉 我沒打清楚 although是從屬連接詞 後面接副詞 03/11 18:03
8F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 子句 03/11 18:03
9F：推 eu1986: 覺得although要放在new one那句才對 03/11 18:03
10F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 能接不是句子的連結詞 只有but and or 03/11 18:05
11F：推 eu1986: 請問S大 本句but連接那兩個詞或子句 我拆解不出來 謝謝 03/11 18:21
12F：→ SINORNITHOSA: new ones are coming in, but (new ones are) pro 03/11 20:17
13F：→ SINORNITHOSA: bably not as quickly as the ones going out 03/11 20:17
14F：→ SINORNITHOSA: 括弧的地方省略掉了 03/11 20:18
15F：推 eu1986: as quickly as the ones 這一段算形容詞? 03/11 21:15
16F：→ SINORNITHOSA: quickly副詞修飾are coming 03/11 21:25
17F：推 eu1986: 感謝 03/11 22:02
謝謝S大！
結論：but, or, and等連接詞可以連接兩個單字、片語或子句，只要是對等的文法結構就
可，although是連接詞裡面的從屬連接詞，只能接子句，子句要有主詞和動詞，但題目的
句子省略掉主詞和動詞，所以只能用but。
這樣對吧?
※ 編輯: kubturub (123.192.192.237), 03/11/2018 22:14:08
18F：→ SINORNITHOSA: you got it~ 03/11 23:07
19F：→ dunchee: although 也對。參考 03/12 00:25
22F：→ dunchee: although 是有這樣子的用法: 03/12 00:26
24F：→ dunchee: When though introduces only ..... 03/12 00:26
25F：→ dunchee: 但是原題目句子的"not"是代前頭整句(的否定): 03/12 00:27
26F：→ dunchee: not: [new one are coming in]否定 -> 03/12 00:27
27F：→ dunchee: {(new ones are) not (coming in)} {as quickly as ..} 03/12 00:27
28F：→ dunchee: 這跟Usage Note裡頭提到的"introduces only a part of a 03/12 00:27
29F：→ dunchee: clause"不一樣 03/12 00:27
30F：→ dunchee: 題目原句子出自 Costco 的刊物(是用 but)。但是出題人沒 03/12 00:28
31F：→ dunchee: 注意到 although 也是正確用字 03/12 00:28
看來實際上這樣的用法蠻常見的，謝謝！
※ 編輯: kubturub (123.192.192.237), 03/12/2018 14:17:21