SKY 球迷 評語 Edwin van der Sar 5 7.6 Flapped at one cross. Spectator for most of the game. Rio Ferdinand 6 7.1 Didn't have a great deal to do. Rafael da Silva 6 7.7 Occasional display of petulance but defended well. Nemanja Vidic 6 6.9 Strong as ever, but not really tested. Patrice Evra 8 8.0 Superb yet again both in defence and attack. Darren Fletcher 6 6.5 Plenty of effort but most of his work was defensive. Michael Carrick 8 7.0 The best player on the pitch. Broke up City attacks and passed superbly. Park Ji-Sung 6 8.8 Excellent in the first half, anonymous in the second. Wayne Rooney 6 8.5 Worked tirelessly and always a threat. Dimitar Berbatov 5 5.6 Poor. Off the pace and too much broke down when it reached him. Cristiano Ronaldo 5 4.4 Never a major factor and sending-off almost cost his team. John O'Shea (Sub) 5 5.1 Only came on in stoppage time. Ryan Giggs (Sub) 5 5.5 Late substitute, no impact with his side down to 10. http://www.skysports.com/football/user_ratings/0,19768,11065_3023033,00.html M.E.N http://tinyurl.com/67fl3j 7 van der Sar: The Dutchman was surprisingly only a spectator in the first half with just a brave dive in on Robinho needed to keep him occupied. Handling sound when things got slightly busier 8 Rafael: Fergie's faith in the 18-year-old, plunging him into an away derby as a direct opponent against Robinho was vindicated. The teenager was rarely in trouble against his fellow countryman 7 Ferdinand: The Blues never really had much in their locker to upset Mr Cool but he was almost caught a couple of times in second half but rallied when Reds down to ten men 8 Vidic: Took care of Benjani with his usual power. The big Serb was the dominant Red at the back and provided great late rearguard action 8 Evra: Took the game to City right back Richards and gave the England prospect a tough time with some penetrative attacking. Defensively was well on top also 6 Ronaldo: Had a good early chance when he rose above Richards and Dunne but despite City not going down the physical route he couldn't take full advantage. Soft way to be sent-off 7 Fletcher: Put himself on a disciplinary tightrope with two tackles on Wright-Phillips that earned him a first half booking 8 Carrick: He was one calm customer in the heavily manned midfield area. Protected back four well but still never neglected his duty 7 Park: Played a part in Rooney's goal by holding ball up well in a congested area and put in his usual hard working and disciplined shift 7 Rooney: Was back on top of his game. Sent in some dangerous set pieces, a mixture with his little flick offs but poached well for the opener 8 Berbatov: Cool as you like. Just what United have been missing recently. The Bulgarian had space where there wasn't any and City had no answer when he dropped deep Subs: 5 Giggs: (sub Berbatov 83) No late impact O'Shea: (sub Park 90) Hardly saw ball -- ★ ╔╦═╮╔╮ ╭╔╮ ╭╔╦═╮ ╔╮╔╮╭╦═╮╔╮═╮ ☆ ☆ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║╠╣ ║╠╣ ║ ╠╣╠╣╠╬═╣╠╣ ║ ★ ★ ╰╝╰╯╰╝═╯╰╝═╯╚╯═╯ ╰╰╯╯╰╝ ╰╰╝ ╰ ☆ ★ ╔╮═╮╭╦╦╮╭╦═╮╭╦╦╮╔╦═╮╔╮ ╔╦═╮╭╦═╭═╦╮╮ ╔╮ ╠╣ ║ ╠╣ ╚╩╦╮ ╠╣ ╠╬╣ ╠╣ ╠╬╦╯╠╣ ║ ╠╣╚═╬╣ ╰╝ ╰╰╩╩╯╰═╩╝ ╚╝ ╚╩═╯╰╩═╯╰╝╰╯╰╩═╯═╩╯╰═╩╝ --

※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 118.170.109.21