作者graddivcurl (為所應為)
看板Physics
標題Re: [轉錄]嬉皮衝浪手 破解愛因斯坦難題
時間Tue Jan 22 14:41:22 2008
※ 引述《breedy (難得快樂)》之銘言：
: 其實這個衝浪dude(傢伙)可以說是蠻會掰的
: 我在一些理論物理的部落格上轉一圈
: 比較含蓄的說他不敢認同 因為他的方法破壞了所謂的Coleman-Mandula theorem
: 比較直接的就笑他這東西很幼稚 連高中生念點群論就湊得出來
幾件事要說:
(1) Lisi uses the MacDowell-Mansouri (1977, ref#16 in the Lisi paper) trick
to get around the Coleman-Mandula theorem.
(2) Future experiments done with the LHC will show who is right. If SUSY
particles can be detected experimentally, then we will be confident that
string theory is on the right track, and Lisi's theory is fundamentally
wrong. The next few years will be exciting years for fundamental physics.
(3) Lisi is not a stupid person. He double-majored in physics & math at UCLA,
and graduated from UCLA with the highest honors. He got a Ph.D. in physics
from UCSD. With such an excellent academic background, why did he not do what
most Ph.D. graduates normally do (i.e. looking for teaching or research
positions in universities or research institutes)? Instead, he has spent most
of his time following his dreams outside the academic community. Physics
has been nothing more than a hobby to him. Doing such a kind of the things
takes courage and persistence!
--
" An expert problem solver must be endowed with two incompatible
qualities ─ a restless imagination and a patient pertinacity"
--- Howard W. Eves
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 140.128.65.230
1F：推 noonee:我個人不喜歡這樣的說辭 這似乎是在說"他這個聰明總不會 01/22 15:13
2F：→ noonee:幹蠢事吧" 事實上 在聰明的人都會幹蠢事 01/22 15:14
3F：→ noonee: 麼 打錯字 01/22 15:14
4F：→ jjsakurai:不過重點是他敢 至於是不是蠢事 還有各LHC可以驗證 01/22 15:20
5F：→ jjsakurai:我覺得如果能證明自己的理論是錯的 也是很大的貢獻 01/22 15:22
6F：→ jjsakurai:因為有太多物理是 not even wrong.. 01/22 15:22
7F：推 noonee:說的好 推j大 01/22 15:26
8F：推 pipidog:推J大,Bell's inequality的貢獻也是在於證明自己是錯的!! 01/22 18:10
9F：→ pipidog:證明了隱變數不存在,在物理上的貢獻,不亞於機率詮釋這件事 01/22 18:10
10F：推 zealeliot:推這篇文章,希望能有更多這種好文 01/22 19:45
11F：推 sputtering:樓上這只是篇英文文 另外LHC好像可以證明若找不到希氏 01/22 22:12
12F：→ sputtering:粒子就證明超對稱可能錯 實際上我也是跟媒體一樣外行啦 01/22 22:16
13F：推 noonee:誰說的SUSY很難用這種方式證明錯的 因為free parameters 01/22 22:30
14F：→ noonee:太多 真的要是找不到Higgs 就再調啊XD 01/22 22:31
15F：推 breedy:不過重點是Arxiv已經把他的論文從phy-th調到phy-gen 01/22 22:46
16F：→ breedy:所謂phy-gen就是給一般大眾發發文 過科學家的隱的地方 01/22 22:48
17F：→ breedy:而phy-th是真正理論學家發文的地方 要發文還有種種限制 01/22 22:49
18F：→ breedy:之前Arxiv負責人出來道歉說沒有好好審他這篇論文所以調地方 01/22 22:50
19F：→ noonee:是喔！那時調的？我抓的時候還在th那邊 01/22 23:20
20F：推 popux:現在在hep-th耶 01/22 23:42
21F：推 Linderman:眾強者終於出來了XD 01/23 23:39