作者unidon (uni~uni~uni~daisuki~!!)
看板CMWang
标题[外电] Chien-Ming Wang, Occasional Ace
时间Sun Sep 2 09:57:22 2007
新闻来源:
http://www.observer.com/2007/chien-ming-wang-occasional-ace?page=0%2C1
Wang was victimized by a .366 BABIP in August entering today’s game, and had
a 5.46 ERA for the month as a result. His career BABIP mark of .291 has
yielded a career ERA of 3.83.
The problem is that BABIP is not a repeatable skill. Pitchers as skilled as
Pedro Martinez in his prime have seen BABIP go from .325 in 1999 to .217 in
2000. Pedro, however, took the spinning of the roulette wheel out of his
results often, striking out 313 in 213 innings in 1999, while walking just
37. He was able to minimize the damage luck could deal him.
Contrast that with recent Yankee Aaron Small, whose strikeout rate of 4.25
over two seasons in New York bests Wang’s career mark. Small held batters to
a .277 BABIP in his magical 2005 season, overcoming a strikeout rate of just
4.38 to post a 10-0 record and 3.20 ERA. In 2006, with a strikeout rate of
four per nine (but a BABIP that jumped to .388), Small posted an 8.46 ERA.
This is not to say that Wang’s performance will fluctuate as much as Small’
s did (for one thing, Wang’s walk rate remains steady, while Small’s did
not). But pitchers on the low end of the strikeout spectrum are extremely
vulnerable to the variables of baseball luck.
Wang also may not be so lucky with the home run ball, despite his ground ball
tendencies. He’s allowed seven long balls in his 166 1/3 innings this
season. But Seattle’s Felix Hernandez, whose groundball/fly ball ratio is
slightly better than Wang’s, has given up 17 homers in 150 innings. Even
Cleveland’s Fausto Carmona, whose 3.33 ground balls for each fly ball is
significantly better than Wang’s 2.62, has allowed 14 long balls in 173 2/3
innings.
Home run rate also fluctuates from year to year, regardless of the pitcher.
Brandon Webb, who throws a sinker as his main pitch as well, allowed 21 home
runs in 2005, 10 this year. Bruce Sutter, whose sinking action on his pitches
put him in the Hall of Fame, allowed 10 home runs in 101 1/3 innings in 1978,
then just 3 in 99 innings in 1979. And Sutter struck out well over a better
per inning in both seasons, meaning he had far fewer balls in play that could
leave the park than Wang does.
So the next time Ching-Mien Wang pitches, bring your rabbit’s foot to Yankee
Stadium. Rub Freddy Sez’s four-leaf clover for luck. And if you don’t see
batters swinging and missing much, hope the energetic Yankee hitters can come
to the rescue.
---
这篇写得很不专业
看完了但不太想翻 XD
这篇文章下面有九篇comment
几乎都是"totally disagree (with this article)"
有兴趣的可以连到原文网址看一下
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.141.41.90
1F:→ DK2s:根本是来呛的 看最後一段 commemt里有人要他公开道歉了 09/02 09:59
2F:→ geniusw:法西斯战puma 王板战ace 09/02 10:00
3F:→ DK2s:更好笑的是东森新闻 "王建民为何这麽好 美知名刊物告诉你" 09/02 10:01
4F:→ DK2s:就是引用这篇,记者可能英文很差吧 09/02 10:02
5F:推 fizeau:pitchers on the low end of the strikeout spectrum 09/02 10:09
6F:→ fizeau:extremely vulnerable to the variables of baseball luck 09/02 10:09
8F:→ superholy:记者看的应该是同一篇 09/02 10:11
9F:推 derekhsu:这篇明明就是在说王是强运才有这样的成绩 09/02 10:19
10F:推 Piaf:嘿嘿!有一个comment是小弟贡献的...这个作者实在是太偏颇了 09/02 10:31
11F:推 leocheng:那作者屁那麽多有啥用 王还是能赢这麽多场啦 他慢慢屁吧 09/02 10:33
12F:推 belucky:记者英文重修 ( =_= ) 09/02 10:52
13F:推 goetz:大概是隔壁板乡民上去写的^^ 09/02 11:11
14F:推 kauw:这种文大概要到王投五六年都很猛才会消失 09/02 11:13
15F:推 erichito19:其实全垒打的那段是有道理的 09/02 11:23
16F:→ erichito19:王今年飞球变全垒打的比率低到4.5%.. 09/02 11:23
17F:→ erichito19:实在是蛮夸张的数字 09/02 11:24
18F:推 clifflu:老实说 我觉得这篇文章还挺中肯的. 他从两个可能是运气的 09/02 11:30
19F:→ clifflu:角度分析,说明王建民的表现有运气存在。 09/02 11:31
20F:→ clifflu:这一来提示读者可以重新检验某些数据头的定见, 09/02 11:32
21F:推 finals:废文一篇 09/02 11:32
22F:→ clifflu:也提醒王建民表现的一些指标 (三振率等等) 应该算浅显易懂 09/02 11:32
23F:→ clifflu:又合理 09/02 11:33
24F:→ clifflu:算了, 还是直接翻出来, 让大家看看我的解读吧 09/02 11:33
25F:推 hyperforce:这观点是没有错的 要嘘也是嘘台湾记者乱引用吧 09/02 11:42
26F:→ davidyee:没人翻译外电 记者只好硬上了 09/02 11:44
27F:推 adaw:讲的并非毫无道理 但是最後的结论实在很刺眼... 09/02 11:53
29F:推 waqw:another Wang hater? XDD 09/02 12:08
30F:推 applejone:又是K/9... 09/02 12:37
31F:推 pikoto:写的有点偏颇.another Wang hater. 队长季初有说过 球队打 09/02 12:37
32F:→ pikoto:球队打不好就是三个环节无法好好衔接.但是小王出来投就是可 09/02 12:39
33F:→ pikoto:小王就是可以让三个环节配合好好的赢球这不是运气而是 09/02 12:39
34F:→ pikoto:稳定军心 09/02 12:40
35F:推 Annrod:并且他有点仰赖球队的防守功力(绝非洋基的强项)和很大的运긠 09/02 13:12
36F:→ Annrod:这句刚好是矛盾,也可以看出小王到底是不是像大家说的运气 09/02 13:12
37F:→ Annrod:防守明明就是洋基所不擅长的,失分还能这麽低,到底是小王 09/02 13:12
38F:→ Annrod:运气还是小王的实力? 09/02 13:14
39F:→ Annrod:不过我猜这位应该是最近才注意到小王,因为这类的言论在去 09/02 13:15
40F:→ Annrod:年早就很常看过了 XD 09/02 13:16
41F:→ Annrod:(三振率低,所以不是好投手等blahblah) 09/02 13:17
42F:推 jerrywin:下面有几篇comments写的很好 都能电死原文了 09/02 14:06
43F:→ jerrywin:王的BABIP都跟平均差不多 去年还比平均高勒 09/02 14:09
44F:推 pkff8763:运气也是实力的一种....人助自助才是他16胜的原因 09/02 14:11
45F:→ Datow:Sutter靠的应该是快叉 09/03 00:35