作者supercilious (mnemonic)
看板Eng-Class
标题Re: [请益] those 跟whom文法问题
时间Thu Jan 30 02:39:28 2020
※ 引述《scju (QQ)》之铭言:
: 这句我在您文章底下的推文已经说过了,就是「to+名词子句」。
: 可以这样理解:who may it concern?(它可能涉及到谁?)
: 改成肯定句、名词子句的形式放在to後当受词:To whom it may concern(致它可能涉及
: 到的那些人,文言一点就变成「敬启者」)。同样情况,who在to後面,是明显的受词位
: 置,所以用whom。因此这句也不是形容词子句,更不是什麽没有先行词的形容词子句。
whom it may concern是没有先行词的关系子句。
但是关系子句未必是形容词子句,有些是名词子句
这里的whom是concern(vt)的object。
To的object/complement是整个子句whom it may concern。
https://www.thoughtco.com/object-of-a-preposition-op-1691447
https://parentingpatch.com/prepositional-complement-english-grammar/
这里的whom充当复合关系代名词,可算是比较古老的英语用法。
To whom it may concern = To the person(s) whom/who it may concern
再举一个whom充当复合关系代名词的例子:
“whom the god loves dies young”
─ Lord Byron
现代的英语的复合关系代名词是what, whatever, whoever, whomever.
I will give the book to whoever needs it.
whoever可以充当子句的主词。
*I will give the book to whomever needs it.
whomever不能充当子句的主词。
I will give the book to whomever you like.
whomever可以充当子句的受词。
I will give the book to whoever you like.
whoever通常可以代替whomever充当子句的受词,而且比往往whomever更自然。
--
Alice Phillips, former High School Principal at Chicago Public Schools
(2006-2010)
Answered Aug 9, 2018
"Whom it may concern' is a dependent clause thereby being an incomplete
thought although it has a subject and verb. "To whom it may concern" is a
prepositional phrase used primarily as a salutation of a letter when the
receivers of the letter are ambiguous and unknown to the writer of the letter.
3F:推 aqw123: peace for this place 01/30 17:47
※ 编辑: supercilious (111.240.123.24 台湾), 01/30/2020 19:57:30
5F:推 aqw123: 看完了......好专业....好烧脑.... 04/16 13:14
6F:→ aqw123: 读完上面的论点.....我比较信任scju的论述 04/16 13:15
7F:→ aqw123: 大家一起加油! 04/16 13:15