作者Engedi (NT补完计画 )
看板GMAT
标题Re: [问题] CR问题
时间Tue Jun 3 23:29:20 2008
※ 引述《izzylf (风)》之铭言:
GWD-8-Q38
: Unless tiger hunting decreases,tigers will soon be extinct in the wild
: The countries in which th tigers' habitats are located are currently
: debating joint legislation that would ban tiger hunting.Thus, if these
: countries can successfully enforce this legislation,the survival of tigers
: in the wild will be ensured.
: The reasoning in the argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
: that the argument
^^^^
这题看起来像weaken,其实只是叫我们指出原文逻辑哪里错
原文是这样,因为 老虎不绝种 --> 狩猎减少 (p-->q)
所以 立法後=狩猎减少 --> 老虎不绝种 (q-->p ???)
(E)指出原文犯了把p-->q当成q-->p的错误,为正确答案。
(A)与其说无法反驳,不如说他是跟原文矛盾的选项,
原文已经说过"如果能成功执法的话...",本来就没说一定能成功
(B)则是无关选项
当初模考时班上有近八成看到vulnerable就圈了A,包括我 Orz
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 203.73.66.80
1F:推 izzylf:感谢!! 06/04 00:38
2F:→ izzylf:我也是圈a... 06/04 00:39