作者rocky9 (课长)
看板MMA
标题[情报] UFC142 Erick Silva DQ 引起争议
时间Thu Jan 19 08:08:32 2012
Erick Silva DQ puts need for instant replay front and center
原文如下:
Erick Silva rode a roller coaster of emotions at UFC 142. After taking out
Carlo Prater in 29 seconds, Silva celebrated with the loud, Brazilian crowd.
He was brought down to reality when he was informed by referee Mario Yamasaki
that the blows Silva used to knock out Prater were deemed illegal. Though a
replay showed that the blows hit the sides of Prater's head, not the
restricted area on the the back of the head, Silva had been disqualified.
The UFC confirmed that Silva did receive his win bonus and it's unlikely that
this loss will stunt his career's trajectory, but it didn't need to be a
loss. Yamasaki admitted when talking to UFC commentator Joe Rogan that he had
to make the decision in the moment.
"I have to decide right there and then. There's nothing I can do," Yamasaki
said.
In that moment, there was nothing Yamasaki could do. Instant replay does not
have a place in MMA. Though he watched the replay on a giant screen just
moments after the fight ended, the bout was decided.
With the technology already in place for referees to use instant replay,
there is no good reason for MMA not to use it. Instant replay is used in
other major sports. Though it isn't always perfect, it gives referees
confidence on making calls.
Like in other sports, strict parameters of when it should be used would need
to be put in place. For example, it does not make sense to use instant replay
to decide if a fighter was truly knocked out or not because of the
difficulties in restarting a stopped bout. But in the case of a
disqualification, instant replay can and should be used.
网址:
http://0rz.tw/23M2u
Joe Rogan质疑Mario Yamasaki的判决
并且要求他在15000名现场观众面前解释
重播镜头看似只有一拳击中後脑杓
没找到影片连结...
但找到Jon Jones的
http://0rz.tw/TK7xe XD
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 163.30.34.178
※ 编辑: rocky9 来自: 163.30.34.178 (01/19 08:14)
※ 编辑: rocky9 来自: 163.30.34.178 (01/19 08:18)
2F:→ chucky :礼拜天早上看的时候我也觉得判失格很莫名其妙 01/19 10:58
3F:推 KempspeeD :裁判OS:再搞我啊X!!!解释个屁!~ 01/19 11:47
4F:推 FalseGod :这篇也只是在讨论mma该不该用即时重播 01/19 16:08
5F:→ FalseGod :Joe跟观众重播看很爽很清楚 但裁判必须马上决定 01/19 16:08
6F:推 egghan :现在还没有网友讨论JONES的下落肘击因应MMA规则成为 01/19 18:38
7F:→ egghan :杀手级的技巧 配合他杀手击的TAKE DOWN 超有杀伤力的 01/19 18:38
8F:推 egghan :一般格斗系统真的比较少单练这种技巧 但上了擂台 嘿 01/19 18:42
9F:推 goldstein :那个12点6点肘击真的一次鼻子就断了... 01/19 19:30
※ 编辑: rocky9 来自: 114.42.135.169 (01/19 21:35)