作者nwohippo (横冲直撞‧西西波)
看板MUSE
标题Re: [新闻] 「正义无敌」歌迷写信阻乐团参加
时间Fri Mar 2 14:33:01 2007
※ 引述《gaudi (勿扰 勿询问 勿来信)》之铭言:
: 美国乐团受邀来台参加228正义无敌演唱会,不少乐迷感到开心,就有台湾粉丝,透过电
: 子邮子,奉劝他们最好别参加。对此正义无敌发起人Freddy表示活动已圆满结束,暂不提
: 告
: http://news.yam.com/view/mkvideopage.php/20070302990127
这些事情的经过在Freddy的Blog写得很清楚
http://blog.roodo.com/freddylim/archives/2768189.html
: 有访问乐团
: 可惜不是muse
: 不过说真的啦
: 所有乐团应该都是来赚钱和表演的
: 对政治意含应该都是一问三不知
以下是grungester写信问Strike Anywhere主唱Thomas先生给的回应
我从punk板转过来的
虽然他说
"We also know that there is a lot that we don't know ( ha ! ) "
但我并不觉得他们是一问三不知反而还表达了自己的想法
TVBS访问的不是主唱而且一句话就卡掉了
我在现场时因为和朋友唱盘古的歌很激动
有年代新闻的记者想采访我
虽然我也是媒体人但我知我说的话一定会被不完整的采用而拒绝
我的确不知道是否像你说的所有乐团包含Muse都只是来赚钱和表演
也不知道的他们对政治意含是不是一问三不知
但我坚信像宇宙塑胶人和Muse这样的"摇滚乐团"
并不会因为区区想赚钱而在一个不认同其理念的场合表演
转型正义甚至带着政治意涵的音乐活动在国际上是很正常的
可惜到了台湾只会被媒体用"音乐归音乐~政治归政治"二分法
关於这类的讨论请至正义无敌官网看吧
当然你也可以写信问Muse他们对这次活动甚至对台湾政治的看法与想法
应该会很有趣XD
作者 grungester (摇滚客) 看板 punk
标题 Re: [情报] strike anywhere!!!!
时间 Sat Feb 24 12:57:32 2007
───────────────────────────────────────
因为过年时间还蛮多的 我也email给他们
下面是Strike Anywhere主唱Thomas先生给的回应
有简单的提到他们的理念跟立场 多数人应该都能接受吧
如果okay的话 就趁这机会去看他们的表演吧~
---------------
Thank you for your time and clarity. We respect the opinions of EmBlack, and
others who feel that any political solution is playing into the machinery
of war and exploitation . ( that is how I read her point of view in this
issue ) We also know that there is a lot that we don't know ( ha ! ) and
we are grateful for your time and communication on this matter. We live in
a country which uses free speech as a kind of sleeping pill. We also have a
democracy which favors the rich and their profits over all other liberties
and lives. So, we take to heart the debate regarding this show, and our
participation.
Nationalism, and racial division are certainly not social ideas that we want
to support, however unconsciously. . ..
This said, we are still going to perform and speak out, and not compromise
our message OR this opportunity to play our songs for many, many, Taiwanese. . .
If you want to post this for us, I would be grateful.
Thanks to you, AND EM BLack for sharing your views and caring about our
little punk band.
Hope to met you very soon,
Solidarity,
Thomas
Strike Anywhere.
--
当我进入媒体时 我郑重的保证
要奉献一切为阅听人服务 凭着良心跟尊严从事传播工作
事实的真相为我首要顾念
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 218.169.86.154
※ 编辑: nwohippo 来自: 218.169.86.154 (03/02 14:36)
1F:推 skidrow99:同感,推!!!!统媒根本就是选择性的报导 03/02 14:39
2F:→ skidrow99:看SA乐手想表达後面要讲的话,完全被剪掉就知道! 03/02 14:48