作者ivanos (Peel quickly and see)
看板Oasis
标题[分享] A fans review of "Dig Out Your Soul"
时间Sat Oct 25 13:27:03 2008
无聊在AMAZON上看到的，觉得写得不错，除了最後几行，基本上还满符合
我的想法的，转来跟大家分享:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.amazon.com/review/R7ESNYWWHWDAO/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm
O.k., I liked these guys from the start. Liked their music, their attitude,
the covers, even the videos when I got to see them (usually don't care about
those).
Does that make me a fan? Probably. Would I buy anything they spit
out? NO!
This, however, I suggest you get. It's fantastic. Although other
fans over here think it doesn't quite reach Definitely Maybe or (What's the
story)Morning Glory? I don't agree.
The guys moved on - not in a
revolutionary way, but still. I think it's wrong to compare anything to the
early masterpieces. This is another time; the band has evolved and brought us
this: A new Marvel of their art.
"Someone tell me I'm dreaming, the freaks are rising up through the floor" -
the moment I heard that line in Bag It Up, the first song on the album, I was
70% convinced this was for me. The other 30% followed with the next few
chords.
Rock at its best.
Of course the typical Oasis melody patterns are
strewn all over the place, (as f.e. in The Shock of The Lightning or The
Turning) which once again doesn't mean it is a copy of anything they did
before. As I said, they evolved.
Noel (vocals, guitar, drums, keys and electronics) wrote six, Liam (vocals)
three and Gem (guitar, bass, keys) and Andy Bell (bass, guitar, keys) each
penned one song. Zak Starkey plays drums again.
My favorites are the ballad I'm Outta Time and the Mid-Tempo Falling Down,
but I also like the stomping Get Off Your High Horse Lady or The Turning and
Waiting For The Rapture.
Oh, and did I mention the booklet-art? Love it!
If you ever liked what they did, get this.
If you never bought any of their
stuff because you believed others saying Oasis being too close to the Beatles
but you liked the Beatles from the days when they made Revolver, get this,
stop thinking and just listen (and tell those "others" they don't know what
they're talking about - though it's clear the Gallaghers are fans: I'm Outta
Time contains an excerpt from a BBC John Lennon interview.)
If ever you're
still undecided, get this too. I swear you'll grow into it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
我唯一不同意的只有"If you never bought any of their stuff because you believed
others saying Oasis being too close to the Beatles but...get this..."
If you believed that, firstly don't buy "Dig out your soul".
Please buy "Definitely Maybe".
Then buy "(What's the Story) Morning Glory?".
Then buy "Be Here Now".
Then buy "Standing on the Shoulder of Giants"
Then buy "Heathen Chemistry".
Then buy "Don't Believe the Truth".
Then, you could buy "Dig Out Your Soul".
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.70.180.8
1F：推 PatsyGallagh:哦我自己对最後那段的解释是 10/25 22:54
2F：→ PatsyGallagh:这位歌迷在鼓吹，之前认为因为绿洲太近似(仿效)披头 10/25 22:56
3F：→ PatsyGallagh:不想买他们专辑，却还满喜欢披头自Revolver之後作品 10/25 22:57
4F：→ PatsyGallagh:的乐迷，务必要买 "Dig Out Your Soul" 10/25 22:57
5F：→ PatsyGallagh:应该是他认为会喜欢 Revolver 风格的人应该会爱DOYS 10/25 22:58
6F：→ PatsyGallagh:所以他恳请这些乐迷给绿洲新专辑一个机会^^|| 10/25 22:58
7F：推 PatsyGallagh:我个人算是同意这样的看法，我也觉得会喜欢Revolver 10/25 22:59
8F：→ PatsyGallagh:(或比较爱後期披头)的乐迷或许会因为DOYS对绿洲改观 10/25 23:00
9F：→ ivanos:我一直都觉得OASIS不近似披头四 10/25 23:23
10F：推 frdabest:应该只是Noel很爱bootleg披头吧~! 10/25 23:26
11F：推 Lautreamont:我觉得这张的很多吉他pattern神似白碟的某些歌曲 10/27 14:15