看板PhD
标 题Re: [台大研协]三"乌"斗法~全国研究生助学金大呛声
发信站批踢踢参 (Fri Dec 9 02:14:59 2005)
转信站ptt!Group.NCTU!grouppost!Group.NCTU!ptt3
※ 引述《[email protected] (白老鼠)》之铭言:
: 研究生为国家学术的命脉,亦是未来学界的栋梁,在迈向国际化的台湾,教
: 育界的最顶端的学子教育当局您照顾到了吗?研究生年龄至少在22岁(72年次)
: 以上,经济上大多不靠家里的支持,为生活所需必须靠助学金与打零工过生活,
: 教育部以往都有补助研究生固定足够之助学金给研究生,当然研究生必须协助系
: 上工作,但由於大学设立的普及化造成资源分散,形成许多研究生的助学金领不
: 到的情况。助学金问题归纳如下:助学金太少、同校各系所助学金分配不一,助
: 学金太少迫使研究生沦落为教授之廉价劳工,公(研究案)、私(论文指导)不
: 能分明,学术品质自然降低,而到外面打工自然也剥削到研究时间。而助学金分
: 配不均,以台大为例,目前是各系所自行决议均分研究生助学金的多寡,有些系
: 所人数较多形成僧多粥少的现象,有些系所甚至一个月只分到一千多元的助学金
: ,研究生的生活产生极大的压力,如何再谈学术品质。研究生在各研究单位中所
: 受到指导教授不公平的待遇,譬如帮教授作私事或当廉价劳工等是非常常见的,
: 但大多数的研究生为了学位多是敢怒而不敢言,如此恶性循环,台湾的学术品质
: 即无法提升。
I can understand that every Taiwanese postgraduate all got such a financial
issue. However, you got to think:
1. If you decide to suspend your career, or whatever, to take a postgraduate
course, which will majorly benefit yourself. If you are doing a project
which nobody interested in it, why the government need to pay you money
for this? (Don't hassle on me, just think about the economic issue.)
2. Unless you are doing a project, which would benefit the government or
a third-party group, then you stand on a good position to ask payment from
benefiting group. However, such payment should at least under the
consideration of
a. the quality of the work.
b. the efforts spent on the research: the working hours and days.
c. the paying rate.
d. are the payment and duty all written in a contract, which one party fails
to deliver the duty could fact court judgement?
Once you start to think about these, you would soon find, there is not point
to give a same money to every postgraduate. Because, no postgraduates working
equally hard on their research, particularly in Taiwan, which the universities
are usually not well managed. Saying, if you are really a good student working
really hard, are you happy to get the same money as those who only work lasily?
Why not you get more and they get nothing?
Conversely, the school, or the government would have the equal right to
ask the students pay for their uses of the university resources. For example
students could use Internet to download something totally not related to
research, or to print a lot of stuffs not required for studies. They don't
even have to pay a cent for them?! I am sure the latter option would make more
progress on the progress in the country.
: 『要马儿好,更要让马儿吃草』为解决根本之道,唯有解决研究生助学金问
: 题进而提升学术品质,虽然钱非万能,但没钱万万不能。最起码要能解决研究生
: 之学费与生活问题,若教育当局在执行面产生问题,是否请思考『没这麽多奶水
: ,就该考虑别生太多小孩』。
: 台湾大学研究生协会会长 张源修 敬邀
Since protest became a culture in the country last century, there have been
too many protests every day, which ask for more and more and paying less and
less, until eventually they all get everything form nothing.
Think about it.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢参(ptt3.cc)
◆ From: 82.22.90.37
1F:推 norris0140:推 12/09 02:52
2F:嘘 losfer:crapy English and tasteless arguments 12/09 07:21
3F:推 LeChatelier:英文内容的确有很多错误;; 12/09 09:10
4F:→ arpin:crapy or crappy? 12/09 10:42
5F:推 LeChatelier:crappy才 12/09 15:27