作者lerudit (l'Erudit)
看板PhD
标题Re: [问题] 碰到大问题了..
时间Sun Apr 30 20:22:09 2006
※ 引述《Ysen (永远的虾布)》之铭言:
: 实验是就是有一个学长是这样的,想要洗脑跟老师说这样的实验数据是不可能的...
: 他参加国内的某会议报告,报告完底下的台大教授说:你的数据是真的,你很诚实
: 甚至他发表的国际期刊,审稿的写信来问,你的误差怎麽这麽小,老师还是不相信
: ,他只是变成稍微相信,但是他还是认为应该不能那麽大,老师心中的标准就是源
: 自於以前学长的标准..学长因为老师这样的要求一样实验作了4X次,每次重现性都
: 很高..就是因为实验室有一个没做数据的、一个做数据的,一个毕业了一个还苦撑
: ,他也是有所坚持,他也无奈,我看他这样子撑,我知道我如果走下去也会像他一样
: ,这种压力我撑不下来,这种老师不相信你对的压力..我承受不了...所以我才考虑
: 休学这条路>
Nobody here knows your supervisor except you.
So, you need to make decision by yourself.
My suggestion, don't lie to anybody.
That would make your world become narrower.
Although you can get your degree, probably, quicker, you will have to always
worry this for the rest of your life.
Nobody will find out? I don't think so.
Once a famous group publishes too many fake results, the chances being
found out would increase dramatically. Once someone realised your group
was lying, then they would suspect everybody in/from your group.
You can try to convince your supervisor you are right, by showing all your
proofs. However, don't spend ages to do this.
If to change his mind takes few years, I would suggest to go away and to
restart your PhD.
This sounds crazy but it is not stupid.
Suppose you have received good training in your first three years,
you probably would be able to get into some professional work immiediately.
It can still takes you another four years to get your PhD.
Nevertheless, if your current supervisor always thinks he is right and you
don't want to lie, is it possible to get your PhD finished
in another four years?
I might be wrong. However, think about it. Good luck.
--
※ 发信站: 批踢踢实业坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 81.111.56.53
※ 编辑: lerudit 来自: 81.111.56.53 (04/30 20:27)
1F:推 Ysen:thx for your suggestion.. 04/30 22:45
2F:推 lerudit:Not at all. You need to calm down and think. 05/01 08:01
3F:推 mincake:Great 05/05 02:10
4F:推 lwei781:The fact that some NTU professor made that comment 06/13 04:34
5F:推 lwei781:probabily means that she/he knew something is wrong.. 06/13 04:39